It is another relevant decision, in adherence to a long line of Supreme Court (SC) decisions that strengthens the institution.
The highest court of the land recently upheld the requirement of the CES eligibility for appointees to 3rd level or CES classified positions to obtain security of tenure or permanence in the service.
In a decision dated 15 March 2010, the SC First Division reinstated the decision rendered by the Regional Trial Court of Pasay City (RTC-Pasay) and reversed and set aside the decisions of the Court of Appeals, ruling that respondent Mercado’s “termination by the PEZA Board of her appointment, as well as the appointment in her stead of CES eligible by Ortaliz, were not illegal.“ because “prior to her appointment or during her incumbency as Deputy Director General up to the time her appointment was terminated, she was not a CES eligible” and “she had no security of tenure”.
The SC added that “(I)n the CES under which the position of Deputy Director General for Policy and Planning is classified, the acquisition of security of tenure which presupposes a permanent appointment is governed by the Rules and Regulations promulgated by the CES Board”.
The SC, citing its ruling in the case of Amores vs. Civil Service Commission (G. R. No. 170093, April 29, 2009) stated that “(C)learly, for an examinee or an incumbent to be a member of the CES and be entitled to security of tenure, she/he must pass the CES examinations, be conferred CES eligibility, comply with the other requirements prescribed by the CES Board, and be appointed to a CES rank by the President.”
Moreover, the SC dismissed the contention of the respondent that Republic Act No. 8748 (RA 8748) removed the CES eligibility qualification for the positions of Deputy Director General in PEZA since the same was not anymore provided in the said law. The pertinent provisions of RA 8748 for the positions of Deputy Director General reads, as follows, “(T)he director general, shall be assisted by three (3) deputy directors general each for policy and planning, administration and operations, who shall be appointed by the PEZA Board, upon the recommendation of the director general. The deputy directors general shall be at least thirty-five (35) years old, with proven probity and integrity and a degree holder in any of the following fields, economics, business, public administration, law, management or their equivalent.” (emphasis in the original)
The SC ratiocinated that “removing the CES eligibility requirement for the Deputy Director General position could not have been the intention of the framers of the law. It bears noting that the position is a high-ranking one which requires specialized knowledge and experience in certain areas including law, economics, public administration and similar fields, hence, to remove it from the CES would be absurd.” (emphasis supplied)
Date posted: April 21, 2010